Project Information
News & Notes
  Documents Highlights
  What's New?
  Press Clippings

Arts & Humanities
Jewish History
Costume & Textiles

Search
Guestbook
Help
Document Highlights
March 2002


LOVE IN THE SHADOWS

PRESENTED BY: The Staff of The Medici Archive Project (with thanks to Kelley Helmstutler Di Dio who discovered the document.)
DATE: 26 April 1581
PLACE: Avviso from Madrid

DOCUMENT CITATION:
Archivio di Stato di Firenze, Mediceo del Principato 3254, unpaginated (Entry 10239 in the "Documentary Sources" database.)

TRANSLATION:
On Holy Wednesday in the Church of the Descalzas [Reales] in Madrid, founded and richly endowed by the Princess of Portugal, a most ugly and scandalous event took place. When they performed the rites of the tenebrae, which normally last for half an hour without light of any kind, many of the chief gentlemen of these kingdoms found themselves near to various noble women. Incited by the darkness and the devil, they affronted these women, wanting at first to kiss them and then go even further. Even if the women cried out, they were foiled by the noise of banging and were thus not heard, which resulted in further insolent behavior. Various of these men were imprisoned, including the Prince of Ascoli, the Conte de Castagneda eldest son of the Marchese de Aguillar, the Marchese de Carpio eldest son of Don Diego de Cordova, Don Pedro Vanegas son of Don Luis Master of the Queen’s Horse, Don Antonio Manrique, Don Luis de Cordova, the Conte de Peredes and Don Enrico de Mendozza. This, it seems, will be to the detriment of the court since they are all principal gentlemen. It is believed that His Majesty [King Felipe II] will have to make an exemplary lesson since the Holy Inquisition has become involved.

TRANSCRIPTION:
[...] Il mercoledì santo nella chiesa dellas Descalzas di Madrid, fondata et riccamente dotata da la Prencipessa di Portogallo, successe un caso bruttissimo et molto scandaloso, et fu che trovandosi molti cavalieri de'principali di questi regni a gl'uffici divini presso alcune dame nobile quando si facevano le tenebre, che sogliono durare mezz'hora senza sorte alcuna di luce, invitati da l'oscurità et dal demonio, havevano affrontato esse dame, cominciando a volerle baciare et anco passar più oltre perchè se ben gridavano impedite dal rumore del battere non erano sentite, facendo anco molte altre insolenze. Per il che furono prigionati alquanti di loro, fra quali il Prencipe d'Ascoli, il Conte di Castagneda figliuolo maggiore del Marchese d'Aguillar, Il Marchese de Carpio figliuolo maggiore di Don Diego di Cordova, Don Pedro Vanegas figliuolo di Don Luis, che fu cavallarizzo maggiore della Regina, Don Antonio Manrique, Don Luis de Cordova, il Conte de Peredes, et Don Enrico de Mendozza, tutti principali, de'quali pare che la corte patisca. Credesi che S. M.tà debba farne essemplar demostratione sendovisi intromessa la S.ta Inquisitione [...]

HISTORICAL CONTEXT:

The rite of the Tenebrae or "The Darkness" is one of the most compelling observances of Holy Week, the period between Palm Sunday and the Easter of the Resurrection. During this time, the custom is to commemorate the Passion of Christ by recreating it: his last days, his death and his rising from the dead. Strictly speaking, the Tenebrae is the monastic service for Matins and Lauds, which should be sung in the first hours of the morning on the three last days of Holy Week (Thursday, Friday and Saturday), offering a tangible parallel to the three days that Christ lay in the tomb before his resurrection. Until 1950, however, the Tenebrae was normally anticipated on the afternoon of the preceding days (Wednesday, Thursday and Friday) in order to encourage public attendence at these offices.

The Tenebrae takes its name from one of the responses in the liturgy:

Ténebrae factae sunt, dum crucifixíssent Jesum Judaei: et circa horam nonam exclamávit Jesus voce magna: Deus meus, ut quid me dereliquísti?

Darkness fell when the Jews crucified Jesus. And around the ninth hour Jesus exclaimed with a great voice, "My God, why did you abandon me?"

In practice, the Tenebrae service offered a dramatic reenactment of this cosmic darkness. The candles in the church were gradually extinguished, leaving the scene in near or total obscurity. Since the participants were unable to see each other, movements (like rising or kneeling) were signaled by sounds of knocking or tapping. After the last psalm, the congregation joined in a general clamor of loud banging, recreating the natural upheaval that took place at the time of Christ’s death.

The astonishing sacrilege (or at very least, astonishing silliness) described in the present avviso took place in the convent of Nuestra Señora de la Consolación, called the "Descalzas Reales" in honor of the unshod royal nuns who occupied it. The Descalzas Reales had been founded by Felipe II’s sister Juana de Austria (1535-73) as a place of decorous retirement only a stone’s throw from the fortified medieval palace of the Alcázar, which was the chief royal residence in Madrid. In 1552 Juana married João Aviz, King of Portugal but was left a widow only two years later at the age of 19. She then returned to Spain and built this convent on the site of the palace in which she had been born, living there from 1559 until her death in 1573, when she was buried within its precincts.

The Descalzas Reales quickly developed a distinctive identity as a privileged dependence of the court, frequented by its most illustrious members. In 1581, the year of the present avviso, another of the King’s sisters took up residence there: María de Austria (1528-1603), widow of the Holy Roman Emperor Maximilian II von Habsburg (1548-76.) Shortly thereafter, in 1584, she was joined by her daughter Margarete von Habsburg (1567-1633), who eventually achieved the position of mother superior. Later inhabitants included Caterina Maria d’Este (1613-28; grand-daughter of Infanta Catalina Micaela di Savoia), Anna Dorotea von Habsburg (1612-?; natural daughter of Emperor Rudolf II), Mariana (entered 1646; natural daughter of Cardinal Infante Fernando de Austria) and Margarita (entered 1656; natural daughter of Juan José de Austria.)

What exactly happened on 22 March 1581, the Wednesday of Holy Week? In fact, the Tenebrae was probably the only time during the entire year when such heedless acts could have taken place, under the cover of these peculiar rites. Though we know that courtiers made outrageous advances to noble women, there are various points of local liturgical usage that would have affected the mechanics of the operation. At what time of day did the service take place and how dark was the church? A common hour for the Tenebrae was four or five in the afternoon, though the windows might have been shuttered or curtained in any case. Did the church in fact remain totally unilluminated for a full half-hour, as the avviso claims? This would represent a deviation from the better-known custom of gradually extinguishing the candles. How long did the noise of banging or pounding last at the end of the service? This would have defined the narrow opportunity for amorous adventure. Finally, were the men and women segregated in different sections of the church? If the caballeros had to cross a significant distance to reach their prey, the risk (and thus the sport) would have been notably enhanced.

The avviso identifies various of the noble adventurers while shielding the ladies from further unwonted attention. However, there is some unclarity and inconsistency in the list, as if the avviso-writer was repeating at second or third hand the names of people he did not quite know.

"Il Prencipe d'Ascoli" was presumably Antonio de Leyva (active 1570-1588; ID Number 10292 in the Project’s "PeopleBase" system), third Principe de Ascoli, son of Luis de Leyva (died 1570). He married Eufrasia de Guzmán and their son Antonio Luis became the fourth Principe de Ascoli.

"Il Conte di Castagneda figliuolo maggiore del Marchese d'Aguillar" was presumably Bernardo Manrique de Lara, Conde de Castañeda (PeopleBase 14066), the third son of Luis Fernández Manrique de Lara. Bernardo was Marqués de Aguilar de Campóo and in 1586, he married Antonia de la Cerda y Aragón, daughter of the fifth Duque de Medinaceli.

"Il Marchese de Carpio figliuolo maggiore di Don Diego di Cordova" and "Luis de Cordova" are presumably the same person: Luis Ramón Folch de Cardona de Aragón y de Córdoba (1558-1596; PeopleBase 14147), son of Diego Fernández de Córdoba.

"Don Pedro Vanegas figliuolo di Don Luis, che fu cavallarizzo maggiore della Regina" was presumably Pedro Venegas de Saay Figueroa (PeopleBase 11593), son of Luis Venegas de Figueroa, who had been Master of the Horse to Queen Anna von Habsburg-de Austria (d.1580). By Holy Week of 1581, Pedro Venegas was already well-advanced in a distinguished military career: he broke the Moorish siege of the city of Melilla in 1563 and was named Comendador de Valencia in the Order of Santiago in 1579.

"Don Antonio Manrique" and "il Conte de Peredes" are presumably the same person: Antonio Manrique de Lara y Manrique de Lara (PeopleBase 14143), the eighth Conde de Paredes de Nava, who died in the wreck of the Invincible Armada in 1588.

"Don Enrico de Mendozza" remains to be identified.

However angry Felipe II might have been, it does not seem that any of these young men finished their courtly careers in the dungeons of the Inquisition. And when it got down to it, everyone involved was probably eager to forget the ludicrous escapade as quickly as possible. Though the Spanish court was known for its uncompromising religious austerity and crushing ceremonial etiquette, there were also startling outbreaks of undisciplined behavior, which thrilled avviso-writers and avviso-readers across Europe.

SPECIAL THANKS to Niccolò Capponi for his notes on Catholic liturgical practice and Lisa Goldenberg Stoppato for her biographical researches.

ILLUSTRATION NOTES:

The Convento de Nuestra Señora de la Consolación in Madrid, known as the Descalzas Reales.
"Ténebrae factae sunt, dum crucifixíssent Jesum Judaei" ("Darkness fell when the Jews crucified Jesus") from the service of the Tenebrae. Breviarium Romanum, ?1959, Courtesy of Count Neri Capponi.

(click image to view larger version)

To the Document Highlights Archive

Documentary Sources for the Arts & Humanities
is the sole property of THE MEDICI ARCHIVE PROJECT INC.,
a non-profit corporation registered in New York with
Federal 501(c )(3) tax-exempt status.

For further information please contact:
info@medici.org

 


© 2001 by The Medici Archive Project